The Massachusetts State Police put together a case against Thomas Lally first. By October 25, 2002, several troopers and detectives were heading over to his Taunton Avenue home in Norton to pick Lally up and charge him with Marina's murder.

Lally gave himself up without so much as a snort.
Sergeant Kevin Shea, from the Massachusetts State Police, and Lieutenant Paul Keenan, from the Quincy Police Department, brought Lally into an interview room inside Norton Police Department.

Shea went through procedure and had Lally agree and sign all of his Miranda rights into effect.
"We have information," Shea started out, "that leads us to believe that you were involved with Anthony Calabro and Jason Weir in conspiring and killing ... Marina Calabro."
What did Lally have to say for himself?
He looked disheveled and beaten down. Nervous. Edgy.
Caught.
All those episodes of crime shows, all that Internet study, well, it was meaningless now.




